Crisp guanciale, eggs, pecorino romano and plenty of black pepper: carbonara is perhaps the best-known Italian dish in the world, and in Rome everyone has their own idea of how to make it. Yet, unlike almost every other traditional dish, carbonara is young: the first written traces only appear in the mid-twentieth century. And there is still no certain answer about how it was born.
First came the name
The name «spaghetti alla carbonara» first appears in print in 1939, in a Dutch East Indies newspaper that lists it among the dishes of a Trastevere trattoria without explaining how it’s made. In 1950 La Stampa reported that American officers had for years been looking for «spaghetti alla carbonara» in Trastevere trattorias. Again, no recipe.
The first recipe? In Chicago
The first known written recipe dates from 1952 and doesn’t come from Rome: it’s in an illustrated book published in Chicago, Patricia Bronté’s «Vittles and Vice», about the dishes of the city’s restaurants. In Italy carbonara appears in a magazine in 1954, in La Cucina Italiana, but with pancetta, garlic and Gruyère. The same year the English writer Elizabeth David included it in her «Italian Food». Guanciale and pecorino only became standard in recipes between the late 1950s and the 1960s.
Legend or history?
There are only theories about its origins. The most romantic links it to the charcoal burners (carbonai) of the Apennines, who supposedly cooked pasta with eggs, cheese and pork fat in the woods; others think of the Carbonari, the secret society of the Risorgimento. The most debated places its birth in the Second World War, when Italian cooking met the rations of American soldiers, rich in bacon and powdered egg: the cook Renato Gualandi said he made it in 1944 for the Allies. None of these theories is proven.
The ancestors
Carbonara may be young, but its ingredients are not. Pasta dressed with cheese and eggs was already documented in the nineteenth century, and central Italy had long had pastas with guanciale and pecorino, such as gricia. In 1931 a Touring Club Italiano guide described a pasta from Cascia and Monteleone di Spoleto, in Umbria, that some consider an ancestor of carbonara, although it had no cheese.
Today’s rules
Roman carbonara today has few ingredients and no secrets: guanciale browned without adding other fat, egg yolks (or whole eggs) beaten with pecorino romano and black pepper, pasta drained al dente and tossed off the heat with a little cooking water until the cream comes together without turning into scrambled egg. No cream, no garlic, no onion: in Rome, anyone who adds them should be ready for an argument. The pasta shape is a personal choice: spaghetti, rigatoni or mezze maniche.
Where to taste it: trattorias in Rome on foood → our guide to Roman trattorias →
Sources
- Wikipedia, «Carbonara», with the sources it cites: La Stampa, 26 July 1950; L. Cesari in Gambero Rosso.
- Gambero Rosso, «Before the Americans: carbonara in Rome in 1939» (Italian).
- Gambero Rosso, «The carbonara of 1954» (Italian).
- Patricia Bronté, Vittles and Vice, Chicago, 1952.
- Sky TG24, «Carbonara Day» (Italian).
